Want to commit a crime? Wipe your shoes, wear your gloves, and, for the love of Queen Victoria, do remember to properly dispose of your tobacco ashes — master detective Sherlock Holmes is coming back to cinemas.

MTV News did a little sleuthing of our own down here in Comic-Con, leaving no clue unturned in discussing the upcoming project with director Guy Ritchie and producer Joel Silver. Ritchie revealed what villain Holmes will face and how his reinvention owes as much to James Bond as it does to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

In the meantime, put on your thinking caps (deerstalker, of course, with an argyle pattern). Given the action oriented tone of Guy Ritchie’s “Sherlock Holmes” reinvention, who should play trusted confidant Dr. John H. Watson and arch-nemesis Professor Moriarty? Keep in mind that Holmes himself will be played by Robert Downey Jr. Sound off on your thoughts on the upcoming project, including who you think should play the key roles, below!